5 Common Coffee Brewing Mistakes You Might Be Making
The Coffee Collect is reader supported. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission—at no extra cost to you. Your support helps us continue sharing coffee inspiration, tips, and discoveries with this community. Thank you for being a part of our coffee journey!
If you’ve ever taken that first sip of your morning cup and thought, “Hmm… something’s off,” you’re not alone. Brewing coffee is both an art and a science—and sometimes even the most passionate coffee lovers make small mistakes that affect the taste in a big way. The good news? These common errors are easy to fix once you know what to look for.
At TheCoffeeCollect.com, we believe coffee should be a joyful ritual, not a frustrating guessing game. Let’s walk through five common coffee brewing mistakes (and how to fix them) so your next cup is your best yet.
1. Using Pre-Ground Coffee
Pre-ground coffee might be convenient, but it loses its freshness quickly after grinding. This means you’re missing out on the bold flavors and aromas that make coffee shine.
The Fix:
Grind your beans just before brewing. A burr grinder gives you control over consistency and freshness. Using a burr grinder elevates your coffee routine. Trust me, once you start using freshly ground coffee every morning you won’t be able to go back.
2. Ignoring Grind Size
Grind size plays a huge role in flavor. Using the wrong grind for your brewing method often leads to under-extraction (sour taste) or over-extraction (bitter taste).
The Fix:
- Match your grind size to your brewing method for balanced flavor.
- Check out our Coffee Grind Size Guide for simple instruction
Click to Read: The Best Burr Coffee Grinders
3. Brewing with Old or Stale Beans
Coffee doesn’t last forever. If your beans have been sitting open on the counter for weeks, you’re probably drinking dull, flat coffee.
The Fix:
Buy freshly roasted beans in small batches and store them in an airtight container away from light and heat. Bonus tip: Skip the fridge or freezer—it can mess with the oils that give coffee its flavor.
4. Using Tap Water Without Thinking Twice
Coffee is 98% water, so the water you use matters. Tap water that’s too hard, too soft, or has a strong taste can ruin your brew.
The Fix:
Simply use the water that tastes the best to you 😉
5. Not Experimenting with Brew Methods
Falling into the same coffee routine every day can keep you from discovering the unique flavors and methods that the coffee world has to offer. Each brew method—French press, pour-over, espresso, AeroPress, cold brew—brings out different notes.
The Fix:
Switch things up! Try your favorite beans in a new method and pay attention to the flavor differences. Coffee isn’t one-size-fits-all; experimenting helps you find what you truly love.
Brew Better, Sip Happier
Making small adjustments to your coffee routine can completely transform your morning ritual. Whether it’s grinding fresh, experimenting with new brew methods, or simply upgrading your water, these fixes help you unlock richer, smoother, and more balanced flavors in every cup.
We’re here to help you celebrate the art and science of coffee—without the guesswork. So, the next time you brew, keep these tips in mind and enjoy the difference in your cup.
What’s the biggest coffee brewing mistake you’ve made and how did you fix it? We’d love to hear your story!
Don’t forget to join the coffee community on Instagram @the.coffee.collect!
-the coffee collect.